Buying your first pellet grill: what r/pelletgrills owners recommend
Last checked Nov 18, 2026 · How we check
In the threads we read, budget buyers get pointed to Z Grills and Pit Boss, and buyers with about a thousand dollars get pointed to recteq and the Weber Searwood. Owners also stress a PID controller and hopper size for overnight cooks.
The facts, with sources
| Item | What we found | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Owner report (r/pelletgrills) | Top answers in a 'first pellet grill for 1k' thread: recteq, then Weber SearwoodWhat the source says[39] Recteq ... [15] I think I would do Recteq at that price range ... [11] Weber Searwood XL | reddit.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Owner report (r/pelletgrills) | Commenters steering a buyer away from the Pro 22 cite its lack of a PID controllerWhat the source saysTraeger doesn't have a PID controller and is the most expensive. So I would rule that one out. | reddit.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Owner report (r/pelletgrills) | Z Grills owner: 6 years, over 1,000 meals on a 700 sq in modelWhat the source saysI have had a Zgrills 700 sq inch grill for 6 years. It was an Amazon deal ... I have used it very hard and have over 1,000 meals cooked on it | reddit.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Owner report (r/pelletgrills) | Z Grills owner: support sent a free display and probeWhat the source saysI had an issue with the display and the temp probe was not reading correctly. Contacted customer service and they sent me a free one of each. | reddit.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Hopper | 28 lb (Z Grills says up to 28 hours)What the source says28-lb hopper — up to 28 hours of non-stop cooking on a full hopper. | zgrills.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Hopper | 18 lbWhat the source says18 lb hopper capacity perfectly sized for everyday cooks without constant refills | zgrills.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
What owners say
- If you had 1k for your first pellet grill: the top replies say recteq, with the Weber Searwood next; one owner says their recteq RT-590 has been solid for years.
- Which cheap small pellet grill should I get?: replies favor Z Grills, mention the PID controller, and remind the buyer that hopper capacity matters for overnight cooks.
- First time buyer: Z Grills vs Traeger: one reply notes pellet grills cook with indirect heat and aren't ideal if you mostly grill burgers and hot dogs.
We don't cover recteq or Weber in detail yet because we couldn't load their spec pages when we checked.